Criteria | Laser Scanning Confocal Microscopy (LSCM) | Spinning Disk Confocal Microscopy | Remarks |
Principle | Uses a single point laser beam scanned across the specimen and a pinhole to block out-of-focus light | Uses multiple pinholes on a spinning disk (Nipkow disk) to illuminate and collect images in parallel | Both provide optical sectioning by rejecting out-of-focus fluorescence, enabling 3D reconstruction |
Illumination | Point-by-point laser scanning | Wide-field illumination through multiple pinholes | Spinning disk is faster due to simultaneous excitation |
Image Acquisition Speed | Relatively slow; limited by sequential scanning | High-speed; suitable for rapid dynamic processes | Spinning disk excels in live-cell and time-lapse imaging |
Photobleaching and Phototoxicity | Higher, due to prolonged and focused laser exposure | Lower, due to parallel low-intensity light exposure | Spinning disk is more suitable for live-cell imaging |
Z-Stack and 3D Imaging | Excellent z-stack acquisition and depth resolution | Good z-stack, but limited by disk geometry | LSCM provides better z-resolution, especially in thick specimens |
Optical Resolution | High resolution, especially in deeper sections | Moderate resolution; better near surface | LSCM allows for more flexible tuning of resolution and depth |
Suitability for Thick Samples | Suitable; can penetrate deeper into thick samples due to stronger laser excitation | Less suitable for thick samples due to light scattering and limited disk penetration | LSCM preferred for deep tissue imaging |
Cost and Complexity | More expensive and complex; requires laser scanners and precise alignment | Less complex; easier maintenance, but requires alignment of spinning components | Spinning disk setups are generally more user-friendly |
Live Cell Imaging | Moderate; limited by speed and phototoxicity | Excellent; ideal for fast dynamic events | Spinning disk is the method of choice for observing fast cellular processes |
Application Areas | Fixed cells, tissue sections, developmental biology, neuroscience | Live-cell imaging, calcium imaging, fast intracellular trafficking studies | Applications are often complementary depending on experimental need |